Someone corrected me this morning — it was a great game, but it was an amazing fourth quarter. True enough. One of the best I have seen. In reality, although the first half was captivating from a storyline perspective, the game itself got a little slow.
So today’s mission: Come up with a list of the best four quarters in Super Bowl history.
Here’s a very quick — emphasis on the very, since we are a little busy this week — take on the best fourth quarters in Super Bowl history. I am sure I missed/misevaluated some because of how quickly I threw this together, so please let me now.
I. Super Bowl XXXVIII: Patriots 32, Panthers 29 — Just in terms of sheer insanity, the one that produced 37 combined points and a game-winning kick in the final moments get the vote. This was the game that officially stamped Tom Brady and Adam Vinatieri as two of the greatest clutch players at their respective positions. Doing it twice is not a coincidence.
II. Super Bowl XLII: Giants 17, Patriots 14 — How do you improve on that? Two stagnant offenses finally burst to life, we see improbable catches by No. 4 receivers, Houdini acts by the least limber of quarterbacks and two fantastic drives. Really great drama, finished off with a last-minute touchdown. Eli Manning outplaying Tom Brady? It really did happen, though the Giants' swarming defense had a little something to say about that.
III. Super Bowl XXXVI: Patriots 20, Rams 17 — The gutsy Patriots start running out of gas, and you can just feel the Rams starting to pick up momentum. I remember when Bill Belichick called his final timeout with 6-7 minutes left, I thought it was a silly error. But his team was whipped. The Rams come back to tie it, and if the game goes to overtime, they win. Period. Instead, the then-boyish Brady “goes out there and slings it” as Drew Bledsoe tells him to, and Vinatieri hits the piece-of-cake 48-yarder.
IV. Super Bowl XXXIV: Rams 23, Titans 16 — Really, it was a boring first half. The Rams dominated yet led only 9-0. They made it 16-0 before the Titans put on one of the more gutsy comebacks in Super Bowl history, tying it at 16-all with 2:12 to play … only to watch Kurt Warner strike immediately back with a 73-yard bomb to Isaac Bruce … only to see Steve McNair and Co. race back themselves … only to see their dreams of tying the game — Would they have gone for two? Sources say no — come up one yard short. I moved this one up the list from where I had it originally: seventh.
V. Super Bowl XXV: Giants 20, Bills 19 — It played out almost like the game above, only the losing team got the ball last. Belichick used the same gameplan in this game as he later did to the Rams in XXXVI. It might actually have been the best overall fourth quarter’s worth of action, but I hate to rank one so high with a missed kick at the end. By you know who.
VI. Super Bowl XXXII: Broncos 31, Packers 24 — People might forget just how good this one was, but it ended a classic. It was tied three times, at 7-all, 17-all and 24-all, the last time in the fourth when the Packers allowed Terrell Davis to score with just under two minutes left to give Brett Favre a chance. Before that, of course, there was the great John Elway helicopter scramble. And John Mobley’s batted pass ended the game.
VII: Super Bowl XXIII: 49ers 20, Bengals 16 — Another one that I almost put higher on the list, and it was a great game overall, but this one can be boiled down to the final drive — the “John Candy Drive” as I like to call it. You know what? Eli’s final drive last night was a lot like Joe Montana’s drive in this game. Let those words sink in for a moment.
VIII: Super Bowl X: Steelers 21, Cowboys 17 — One of the most watched Bowls ever (last night surpassed it), X was a classic of two heavyweights, and who could forget the bomb to Lynn Swann that made his career? He’s in the Hall of Fame for many reasons, but that play, I feel, got him in. Look at his career numbers compared to other HOFers; they are not close. The Cowboys, though, stormed back and could have won on the final play, but Steelers S Glen Edwards picked off Roger Staubach in the end zone.
IX: Super Bowl XIII: Steelers 35, Cowboys 31 — Another great rally. Down 35-17 with under seven minutes left, Staubach threw for two TD passes; the Cowboys even recovered an onsides kick to get the ball back, a Super Bowl rarity. They tried another one, but Rocky Bleier fell on it to end the game. And I hate to say it, but the signature moment was Jackie Smith’s dropped pass in the end zone. The Cowboys kicked a field goal and lost by four. Ouch.
X. Super Bowl V, Baltimore Colts 16, Cowboys 13 — Unofficially the ugliest Super Bowl of all time with all the turnovers and penalties, but V still came down to a last-second kick by Jim O’Brien, a rookie. The Cowboys led, 13-6, at half. But the Colts intercepted two passes in the second half and took the game. I put this one on reluctantly. I almost chose Super Bowl XVI, the first Bengals-49ers matchup, but that was a weird game. I also thought about XIV, Rams-Steelers, but the third quarter was the meat. XVII was pretty solid football, with about 34 John Riggins gut runs, but it lacked drama. What can I say? I go for the cheap thrills over substance every time!