If you just can’t get enough Patriots-Colts talk, here are three more talking heads who yakked about the game
Phil Simms, for my money, is about as good an analyst as there is out there. And I appreciate the fact that everytime I have talked to him or asked a question, he has given it his full though before answering. It really makes a difference.
And heck, Bill Cowher does what few other analysts do: break down the game in easy-to-comprehend, concise verbiage. He’s better at TV than I thought he’d be.
So these three guys, plus CBS News and Sports president Sean McManus, spoke with nearly 50 writers on the phone Tuesday about Colts-Patriots (which of course CBS is doing) and other league matters. Here are some of the highlights of the conference call:
Opening remarks on New England-Indianapolis game:
SEAN McMANUS, President, CBS News and Sports
“These are the kind of games that come along every once in a while during the regular season schedule that you just pray they are going to be on your network. We got a good break with the two teams being undefeated going in and I can’t remember anyone at CBS Sports whether it is the announcers or the pregame crew or the producers and directors being more pumped up for a regular season football game. I thought we were pretty excited about the Cowboys Patriots game, but this exceeds even that. So if Football Gods are willing and we get a good game, I think we are set for a pretty good Sunday afternoon.”
PHIL SIMMS
“What intrigues me, how both of these teams will view their opposition this week and how they will go about trying to win the game. History has showed us, and has showed me as an analyst, that they are both willing to do something different, especially the New England Patriots. So I can’t wait to find out and can’t wait to watch on Sunday.”
BILL COWHER
“Just watching these first eight weeks has been fun to watch. These two teams separate themselves from the rest of league and that is how they are playing right now. These two teams are playing at a higher level than any other team in the league is playing. That we can get a match-up like this halfway through the year is great for the fans.”
JIM NANTZ
“What we have here is the rivalry of its time — the rivalry of its era. It has been this way for a long time since New England had Indianapolis’ number and Peyton couldn’t beat them. Of course they have turned that around in the last three match-ups, coming off the AFC Championship game. We have Dungy and Belichick, Manning and Brady, two high-powered offenses, both undefeated — it is just spectacular.”
On similarities and differences between Indy Head Coach Tony Dungy and Pats Head Coach Bill Belichick and their teams:
COWHER
“These are two guys that have great respect for the game, a great knowledge of the game, and you can just tell by looking at them that the players respond to them. Tony is probably a guy that you will see a little bit more animated on the sideline than Bill. But again, I think these two teams are a little bit different from the standpoint of how the teams were built. Indianapolis built their team through the draft, and New England, a lot of their skill positions were filled through free agency. It is interesting the approach that these two coaches have taken and these two organizations have taken. Both coaches are very much viewed as the cream of the crop as far as the coaching profession in the NFL is concerned.”
SIMMS
“We go to the Colts practices and you never hear the coaches say anything in practice. The only person you really hear at an Indianapolis Colts practice is Peyton Manning because he is telling everyone what to do. His style (Tony Dungy) is so different from Bill Belichick’s. I asked Bill Belichick once before the Super Bowl in Houston, how would you describe your coaching style? And he responded, ‘I coach through fear. I tell people they better play better or I’ll bench them or it will cost them their job.’ That is how he learned. I don’t know if he still coaches exactly that way but he definitely has a different style than Tony Dungy. Their teams, the way the players act you see it all. That is why it has caught the attention of America over the years because even if you don’t follow football you can see the differences in the personalities of the coaches and the teams. You want to watch and see what is going happen.”
On the strength of New England’s offensive line:
COWHER
“When you look at New England and Indianapolis, but particularly New England, that has always been a strength of theirs. The thing that gives credence to that is when you look at both of these quarterbacks. The amount of verbiage they give, and certainly it is well documented with Peyton Manning’s calling plays, you cannot do that unless you have a veteran offensive line who understands it. Tom Brady does the same thing. He is always pointing out the connections and he was one of the toughest guys to get to blitz-wise because he did a very good job of orchestrating that line. You have to have a line that communicates and works with one another. That is something that both of these coaches understand and recognize. I don’t care if you run the ball or pass the ball, if you don’t have an offensive line you can’t do either. It starts right there with the offensive line. That is a big part of the success that both of these teams have had.”
On the Patriots allegedly running up the score:
COWHER
“This is a football team that plays with a tremendous sense of purpose and focus. I’m not so sure that when they’re out there they are even looking at the scoreboard. The fact that you have some of your premier players in the game with the margins being what they are is Bill’s (Belichick) prerogative. That is his decision. The risk that he’s taking is that one of those guys could get hurt in those situations. That is his decision as a coach and he has the right to do that. This is a team that is playing with a tremendous sense of purpose every time they step on the field and Bill has them playing that way right now.”
SIMMS
“I played for a coach in Bill Parcells and he always said to us, ‘I’ll coach my team. That’s all I can do and focus on. Let them worry about themselves.’ A lot of coaches believe you don’t worry about injuries, you play your guys and you can’t protect them. It is bringing up some controversy and I think that always feeds in to helping the New England Patriots. They love controversy…They look forward to the battle and they’re willing to battle from start to finish. You’ve got to prove as the opposition that you are willing to fight that long. All of this really feeds into what they love. They like the turmoil. They like the action. As my dad once said to me, ‘Be careful when you get into a fight with someone who doesn’t care about winning or losing, they just like the action. Be leery of those guys.’ The Patriots love the action. All of this stuff that you read about, everything that has gone on this year, I truly believe feeds into the atmosphere that they love.”
On “Spygate” controversy fueling New England this season:
NANTZ
“I don’t think that there is any question that what they are doing on the field is totally related to what happened at the end of Week 1. All of us in the media took that opportunity to go back and review and somehow attach what happened in the “Spygate” episode and try to take it so far as to say that this stained their three championships. How did they win? Oh, no wonder they won, because they cheated. So now they have had their championships, their integrity, called into question. Maybe it is not verbalized in the sacred setting of the locker room, where it is just the coach and staff and 53 players, maybe it is not something that has to be talked about, but I think they have all internalized it. I think they are inflicting that punishment on a weekly basis with that right at their very core.”
On Brady and Manning:
SIMMS
“When these two guys play each other it is awesome. Tom Brady said we need all week to get ready for this game because you want to cover all of your bases and make sure you’re ready.”
On keys to victory:
COWHER
“The quarterback comparison is an easy one to go to, but if you look at both teams’ defenses, the key is going to be what their approach is to stopping the other team’s offense. Because you have two of the most potent offenses in the National Football League, their defenses are going to have to match that and slow each team’s offense down to some extent.”
SIMMS
“What could be the difference, and I NEVER say, because I am not just one that is all about the quarterback, I just don’t fall into the trap, but it could come down to which quarterback is just in a groove that day. It could be that close. By in a groove, I mean throwing it into windows that are not big, the velocity, the accuracy, it’s all there…Quarterbacks are a lot like pitchers. They have days when they can’t get that rhythm or they’re just missing a little bit. Peyton Manning down in Carolina last week. Physically it took him a while and he had some throws that you just don’t see him make. Look at Tom Brady last year in the playoffs at times. In Indianapolis he didn’t throw the ball physically as well as he is capable of throwing it. There are so many great components to this game, that it just might come down to which one of them is having that great day.”
On whether the Patriots have become a team that people love to hate:
NANTZ
“If there is a good guy and a bad guy set up in this game, I really think the bad guy would be New England with the whole running up the score chatter that is out there today…They’ve gone from that team that was very likeable and the underdog to where now there is this awe factor. I know that all coaches and players are programmed not to look ahead, but sometimes I can’t help myself as a fan. And if you start thinking about New England, if it gets past this game, there are a couple of spots there that they are going to be tested, they’ve got Pittsburgh at Foxborough in December, but now would be the proper time to start thinking about this team in some sort of context. They have the chance to be the ultimate super team…How well though it sets up for Indianapolis? You win 12 games in row including beating New England in the AFC title game. You win the Super Bowl. You’re undefeated this year. The last two weeks you have been pressed to go on the road in a six day stretch, both against teams with winning records, and you blow them out on both occasions. Now you get to come home to your own building and you’re a 4.5-point underdog. You want somebody to give you a chip on the shoulder? Well, there it is.”


I like Shula more than a lot of people in our business. He helped me out one time when Nick Buoniconti -- another '72er -- was elected to the Hall of Fame and blew me off for an interview we had scheduled. Shula called me later and told me a couple of great stories about his former linebacker. I was very gracious for the coach's help, and he spoke to me mere minutes before he was supposed to talk to a room full of CEOs, which made it all the more generous gesture.