I am totally split here and, quite frankly, kind of bummed. Ambivalent isn't even the word. This is fractured, difficult thought I am experiencing right here.
I just watched one of the weirdest games of football I canremember, and all I can think about is one fateful decision by the Bills' coaching staff that lost them this game.
The name of the offensive coordinator of the Bills is Steve Fairchild, a man with a pretty good reputation around the NFL. The head coach, as you likely know, is Dick Jauron, a one-time Coach of the Year with the Bears. Go ahead and blame them now.
Both of these men made a critical decision calling for a pass on third down and nine to go on the Cowboys' 11-yard line. There were six minutes remaining and their team was up eight points with all the momentum. They called for a pass -- out of the shotgun -- towards the sideline. Uh, HELLO? It shouldn't be done. It cannot be done, not in that situation. You're up eight points. At worst, you go up 11 points and make the Cowboys go the length of the field at least once. At worst-case worst, you miss the shorty (under 30 yards) and make them go the length of the field once -- and make the two-point conversion. To tie.
Instead, the floating, wounded duck was shot down by Cowboys CB Terence Newman and ran back about 70 yards, completely flipping the field. Why in the name of Jack Kemp are you tossing that teardrop pass to little Lee Evans at the 5-yard line with no one in the way between the defender and the end zone? Ask any coach in America not named Rich Kotite, and they'll tell you that it's a major sin to call that play in that situation.
I know a million things happened before this play, and a million more happened after it. I know the Cowboys moved down and tied the game on a 12-play drive that showed Tony Romo's guts. But you absolutely don't do two things if you are the Bills in that third-down situation above: you don't line up in the shotgun, signalling -- no, screaming! -- pass, and if you're going to throw it, you throw something safe and over the middle or into the end zone. My goodness.
The quarterback, being fair, was a rookie, Trent Edwards, making only his second career start. The kid's smart, yes -- Stanford smart, even -- but that's even more reason not to call for that play! The Bills don't have an ideal red-zone target, that big 6-4 receiver to throw a jump ball to, but their tight ends had been doing OK against the Cowboys most of the night. Throw it in the back of the end zone to one of them.
If this wreaks of classic rearviewmirrorism, I swear on my grandfather's grave I was up in arms over here
watching the game before and during the play. I respect Fairchild for wanting to step on the Cowboys' neck; you don't give good teams too many chances. But what I am saying is that is a risk that is unnecessary and silly. An 11-point lead changes everything. Now maybe the Cowboys go down the field in 3-4 minutes of gametime, like the they two drives later, and maybe Nick Folk (hero) makes another 50-plus yarder.
Fine. But you're tied. And that's assuming the Cowboys made the two-point conversion. Otherwise, they would have needed to get the ball back after the first score and get another TD. Too tough, methinks.
Put the game in the hands of the defense. They had carried you all night. They made Tony Romo look like any other quarterback from Eastern Illinois, take your pick, and not a league MVP candidate, as he had played up to that game. The defense had made five interceptions, two run back for touchdowns, forced another fumble, and Romo clearly was bothered by the pressure, even if he wasn't sacked in the game. Terrell Owens was bottled up. Marion Barber had done nada. Only Jason Witten had burned them, and he was lumbering there a bit at the end.
The Cowboys, it should be noted, were not free of coaching errors. They flubbed their timeouts, spending their third and final one before going for the would-be tying two-point conversion with 20 seconds left. Sure, they thought they had to get it, but clearly they didn't. They missed and still won. Another timeout allows you to go down the middle of the field with a pass after you recover the onsides kick. It saves you at least one play, and it changes the playbook and the Bills' coverage immensely. Besides, most onsides kicks are recovered somewhere near your own 40. The Cowboys were so fortunate to get that extra kick forward about 8-10 yards on the recovery.
Make no mistake, they are a blessed team right now. But that makes me think even more that they are headed to Glendale for the Bowl. And not because the Packers -- and a few other would-be contenders -- lost on Sunday. It's just that good teams often have an insane game like the Cowboys had last night, and it propels them through the season.
The Bears had that game last season in Arizona, coincidentally, that cost Denny Green his sanity as well as his job. The 2004 Patriots won a wild one in Denver that involved an intentional safety. Almost every Super Bowl team can look back at that one ridiculous game that "sprung" them to having a great season. It's a small dose of humble pie, nearly losing to a bad team, but it's a double scoop of fun because you end up with a W.
(An aside: Normally, I don't think any one game should ever cost a coach a job, but you can point to Green losing his last season because his team didn't bounce back from the Chicago loss they had no business losing, or the Bears had no business winning, you decide. If Jauron gets fired, it wouldn't shock me. It would be a decision based on what happened the entire season, but when you have such a good night and such a phenomenal effort from your team go down the drain like that, with Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas looking on, no less, it's not hard to be demoralized. Just a thought.)
Sunday might or might not be a Super Bowl preview for the Cowboys and Patriots, but it will be an entertaining game, and I found myself slightly rooting for Folk to make the kick, selfishly, because I am going to the game, and I wanted two undefeated teams. But if the Cowboys do make it to Arizona, they can thank the Bills' coaching staff for one small, but meaningful assist along the way.
The saddest part of the whole deal? It was a crazy game, one for the ages, and there are a million things to talk about that came out of it. But I am stuck on one really bad coaching decision. That stinks.